ABOUT US

MilkShake Factory has been perfecting its craft since 1914. At our locally owned Old Town Fort Collins shop, we bring that tradition to life through handspun milkshakes, premium chocolates, and welcoming hospitality.

We’re looking for a Shift Supervisor who enjoys leading people, takes pride in the details, and wants to grow with our business. Join a team where you can build your leadership skills, develop your chocolate knowledge, and be part of the Old Town community.

POSITION OVERVIEW

The Shift Supervisor leads daily shift operations while working alongside team members to deliver excellent service and consistently high-quality products.

This hands-on role requires confident leadership, initiative, and sound judgment. You’ll provide clear direction, coach team members, and follow through to ensure work meets our standards. Keeping the store clean, polished, organized, and welcoming is an essential responsibility.

Advancement is available based on demonstrated performance and business needs.

RESPONSIBILITIES

Lead shifts, delegate tasks, and verify that opening, closing, and daily responsibilities are completed correctly.
Train and coach team members, provide constructive feedback, and communicate performance concerns to management.
Set a positive example, promote teamwork, and help create a professional, enjoyable work environment.
Welcome guests, answer questions, offer samples, recommend products, and resolve concerns professionally.
Prepare milkshakes, sundaes, and dipped chocolates according to recipe, quality, and presentation standards.
Maintain cleanliness throughout the store, including the dining room, restrooms, equipment, service areas, and back-of-house spaces. Assign tasks and check completed work.
Assist with stocking, inventory, product rotation, waste reduction, seasonal displays, and signage.
Follow cash-handling procedures and ensure team members do the same.
Adjust priorities to business volume, keeping the team productive and supporting appropriate staffing and labor management.
Reinforce food safety, sanitation, and workplace safety procedures. Promptly report equipment, safety, or product-quality concerns.
Perform other duties as assigned.

QUALIFICATIONS

Previous food service, hospitality, retail, or customer service experience; supervisory or shift leadership experience preferred.
Strong communication, delegation, and problem-solving skills, with the confidence to hold team members accountable respectfully.
Close attention to cleanliness, presentation, accuracy, and safety.
Ability to prioritize, take initiative, and remain composed during busy shifts.
Cash-handling experience; familiarity with POS systems preferred.
Dependable attendance, clear communication, and consistent availability.
High school diploma or GED preferred.
Must hold a current ServSafe Food Protection Manager certification or obtain it within 30 days of hire. Certification costs are covered by the employer.

SCHEDULE AND PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS

Availability for a mix of weekday opening shifts and weekend evenings, with holidays as needed.
Ability to stand and walk for extended periods, bend, stoop, reach, and lift up to 25 pounds, with reasonable accommodation as applicable.
Manual dexterity to prepare products and operate equipment safely.

WHAT WE OFFER

Hourly pay of $16.00–$21.00, with tips
Free shift shake.
Casual dress code.
Opportunities to develop your chocolate knowledge and dessert-making skills.
Employer-paid ServSafe Food Protection Manager certification.
A place in a locally owned business and the Old Town Fort Collins community.
Opportunities for professional development and advancement.

Compensation: $16.00 - $21.00 per hour

At MilkShake Factory, we're on a mission to craft moments of joy through our handspun milkshakes and premium chocolates. If you're seeking an opportunity to have fun and master the art of desserts, look no further – you've found your place.

We've been busy perfecting our craft since 1914 and we're excited to expand our legacy with you. Joining our team comes with SWEET perks:

Enjoy a 'chill' work attire
Be part of a rapidly growing concept
Develop into a chocolate-tasting expert – other chocolates will never taste the same
Become a valued member of a cool team and local neighborhood community

Embark on a journey with us where there is room to grow and develop internally

Come shake things up with MilkShake Factory!

Exciting news - we're expanding our operations coast to coast! Check out our openings at our franchise locations or join us in our hometown of Pittsburgh, PA.

_{This franchise is independently owned and operated by a franchisee. Your application will go directly to the franchisee, and all hiring decisions will be made by the management of this franchise. All inquiries about employment at this franchise should be made directly to the franchise location, and not to MilkShake Factory Corporate.}

(if you already have a resume on Indeed)

Or apply here.

* required fields

First Name*

Last Name*

Email*

Phone*

Text me updates about my application

Yes No

Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Reply STOP to opt out. Reply HELP for help. See our User Terms of Service and Privacy Policy for details.

Location

Address

City

States

ZIP Code

Resume/CV (optional)

Type/Paste Text

Cover Letter

Type/Paste Text

Recent Job Title

Recent Employer

What days and hours can you consistently work, including weekday openings and weekend evenings?*

Describe a time you led a shift or directed coworkers. How did you ensure tasks were completed?*

Do you hold ServSafe Manager certification?*

Referral code from a current employeeIf no code provided, add their name instead.

Enjoy a 'chill' work attire

Be part of a rapidly growing concept

Develop into a chocolate-tasting expert – other chocolates will never taste the same

Become a valued member of a cool team and local neighborhood community